A striking critique of President Donald Trump’s leadership style has emerged from John Ullyot, a former deputy assistant during his second term. Ullyot claims that Trump is becoming a “visible embarrassment,” primarily due to the influence of his family and staff, whom he deems too accommodating.
“Ultimately the buck stops with the President,” Ullyot told The New Yorker, emphasizing that while Trump’s team may share the blame, the ultimate responsibility lies with him. “He deserves better from his staff, but above all he deserves better from himself.”
Ullyot, who served as a senior adviser during Trump’s 2016 campaign, noted that a successful leader should foster an environment where staff feel empowered to offer honest feedback instead of mere praise. “He needs to have staff that are not yes-men,” Ullyot added.
Reflecting on Trump’s approach to governance, Ullyot observed that televised Cabinet meetings more closely resemble a cheerleading session than serious business. During these events, Cabinet members compete to express their admiration for the President, a dynamic Ullyot critiqued as counterproductive.
To illustrate his point, Ullyot referred to Ford CEO Alan Mulally, who famously encouraged his team to provide honest assessments during times of corporate difficulty. He recounted how Mulally celebrated an executive who was candid about bad news, eventually promoting him. “Mulally wanted to hear the bad news, probably before the good news,” Ullyot stated.
Contrasting this with Trump, Ullyot suggested that the current President has a tendency to avoid facing uncomfortable realities, instead favoring positive news. This preference, he argues, perpetuates a cycle of sycophancy within his administration.
Ullyot argued that Trump began with clear promises during his campaign—ending perpetual wars, cleaning up Washington, and placing America first. In his previous term, he seemed more committed to these goals, albeit interspersed with notorious incidents of late-night tweeting and TV watching.
During the interview, New Yorker writer Isaac Chotiner reminded Ullyot that Trump’s focus has often appeared scattered. “It was a lot of tweeting in the middle of the night. It was a lot of staying in the residence to watch Fox News,” Chotiner pointed out.
Ullyot agreed, acknowledging that what has changed is Trump’s diminished focus on implementing his key pledges. His distractions, Ullyot claimed, now include family issues that seem to exploit his name for personal gain.
When Chotiner suggested that family influences might be to blame, Ullyot confirmed, saying, “It’s his family. This was not a visible embarrassment in the first term. Now it’s a visible embarrassment.”
Ullyot added that Trump appears taken aback by the surrounding controversies, implying that the President could benefit from setting a firmer tone in his current administration. “He should have set the tone in the second term and said, ‘No more of this B.S.,’” he asserted.
Responses to Ullyot’s comments have varied, highlighting a growing divergence in perceptions of Trump’s leadership. Observers note the increasing frequency of such criticisms from within his circle.
The former aide’s insights raise intriguing questions about the dynamics at play in the White House and the nature of accountability among those in positions of power. As debates about leadership styles continue, Trump’s presidency remains a focal point.
Trump’s supporters may argue that his unconventional style has resonated with a significant portion of the American populace, fueling his continued political relevance. Critics, however, warn that a lack of constructive criticism among close advisers could lead to detrimental consequences.
As Trump’s second term unfolds, the interplay between his leadership approach and the effectiveness of his team is expected to remain under scrutiny. The coming months may reveal whether Ullyot’s concerns will spark changes in how the President receives and processes information.
For Trump, the stakes are high. With the 2026 midterm elections approaching, the pressure to project strong leadership and fulfill his campaign promises will only amplify as he attempts to solidify his legacy.
As the political landscape evolves, the ramifications of Ullyot’s assessment of Trump’s presidency could play a pivotal role in shaping public perception and influencing the future direction of the Trump administration.
