A Senate hearing meant to put former special counsel Jack Smith on the defensive instead produced one of the most awkward political moments of the week.
And Sen. Katie Britt’s face ended up telling much of the story.
Missouri Republican Sen. Eric Schmitt was questioning Smith during Tuesday’s Senate Judiciary Committee hearing when he accused the former prosecutor of lying about where he had been on Feb. 3, 2024.
Schmitt suggested he had evidence placing Smith at an Atlanta Hawks basketball game in Georgia — a potentially significant allegation because Schmitt was trying to connect Smith to Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis and prosecutor Nathan Wade.
There was just one major problem.
Smith had not been at an Atlanta Hawks game.
He had been watching the Iowa Hawkeyes play Maryland in College Park.
The distinction destroyed the premise of Schmitt’s attempted confrontation.

And as the mistake became apparent, cameras turned toward Alabama Republican Sen. Katie Britt sitting nearby.
Footage showed Britt with her mouth open and eyes widened before she slowly changed expression as Smith explained where he had actually been.
The clip quickly spread online, with viewers interpreting her reaction as the instant Schmitt’s error became obvious.
What Britt was personally thinking cannot be known from a camera shot alone.
But the timing of her visible reaction made the moment especially striking.
Schmitt had entered the exchange aggressively.
Earlier in the hearing, he told Smith: “You will go down as a total dirtbag.”
Then he shifted toward what appeared to be his dramatic piece of evidence.
“What would you say if I had a series of text messages from your team that said you were in Atlanta at a Warrior-Hawks game on February 3, 2024?” Schmitt asked.
He then warned Smith to take a moment before answering so that he would not “perjure” himself.
Smith looked at the material and pushed back.
He said he did not remember attending an Atlanta Hawks game and did not recall traveling to Atlanta as special counsel.

Then the actual event began coming back to him.
“I recall going to a University of Maryland basketball game where Caitlin Clark was playing,” Smith said.
He suggested checking whether Maryland had played Iowa around that date.
They had.
On Feb. 3, 2024, Iowa defeated Maryland 93-85 at the XFINITY Center in College Park.
Caitlin Clark scored 38 points and added 12 assists in front of a sold-out crowd of 17,950.
Then Sen. Amy Klobuchar stepped in.
“Is it the Hawkeyes?” she asked.
Yes.
The apparent source of Schmitt’s mistake was suddenly obvious.
Hawks. Hawkeyes.
Two entirely different teams, two entirely different leagues and two entirely different cities.
One was the NBA’s Atlanta Hawks in Georgia.
The other was the University of Iowa Hawkeyes women’s basketball team playing hundreds of miles away in Maryland.
The Associated Press later confirmed that Schmitt had conflated the two while attempting to question Smith about his whereabouts.
Klobuchar was not impressed.
“I think people should have their facts straight before they accuse someone of being a dirtbag,” she said during the hearing.
The remark landed particularly hard because Schmitt had already accused Smith of dishonesty and raised the possibility of perjury before establishing the basic facts behind his claim.
The broader hearing was far more serious than the viral basketball mistake.
Smith had been called before the Judiciary Committee to defend his investigations into Donald Trump.
As special counsel, Smith led the federal criminal cases involving Trump’s attempts to overturn the 2020 election and his retention of classified documents after leaving office.
Both federal cases were ultimately dismissed before trial after Trump returned to the presidency.
At Tuesday’s hearing, Republicans accused Smith of politically motivated investigative tactics, including obtaining phone records involving Republican lawmakers.
Smith rejected those claims and defended the work of his team.
“Our investigation developed proof beyond a reasonable doubt that President Trump engaged in serious crimes against our nation,” Smith told senators.
He also said he would not be intimidated by threats that he could himself face prosecution.
Republicans raised substantive questions about subpoenas involving lawmakers and others connected to the Jan. 6 investigation.
Even some commentators who criticized Schmitt’s basketball error noted that those broader questions about investigative methods remained separate from his failed attempt to place Smith in Atlanta.
But Schmitt’s mistake quickly became the hearing’s viral moment.
The Washington Post described the exchange as a failed “gotcha” after Smith’s account was confirmed.
Video and records placed Smith at the Maryland-Iowa game rather than at an Atlanta NBA event.
The timing created another political wrinkle.
Hours before the hearing, Axios had published a story about Schmitt’s growing relationship with Vice President JD Vance and speculation that the Missouri senator could eventually emerge as a potential running mate in 2028.
That report described Schmitt as someone viewed by allies as politically skilled and close to Vance.
The hearing then provided him with a far less flattering burst of national attention.
Still, one bad exchange does not determine a politician’s future.

Nor does Schmitt’s factual mistake resolve the larger disputes surrounding Smith’s investigations.
But as televised political moments go, the sequence was difficult to ignore.
Schmitt began by accusing Smith of potentially lying under oath.
He produced what he believed was evidence placing the former special counsel in Atlanta.
Smith said he had been watching Caitlin Clark play basketball in Maryland.
The records backed Smith up.
And sitting only a few feet away, Katie Britt’s expression changed as the entire argument collapsed in real time.
Sometimes congressional hearings produce hundreds of pages of testimony.
Sometimes they produce one unforgettable camera shot.
