A retired Navy admiral is warning that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s sweeping personnel decisions could inflict lasting damage on the United States military—driving out experienced leaders, discouraging female recruits and politicizing the promotion process at a dangerous moment.
John Kirby, who served nearly three decades in the Navy before retiring as a rear admiral, delivered the blistering assessment in an opinion piece for MS NOW.
Kirby argued that the resignation of Army Secretary Dan Driscoll should not distract Americans from the deeper transformation unfolding inside the Pentagon.
“The resignation of Army Secretary Dan Driscoll should not overshadow some disturbing facts,” Kirby wrote.
According to his account, Hegseth has fired or blocked the promotions of more than 80 generals and admirals—approximately 10 percent of America’s most senior military officers.
“His personnel and policy decisions are threatening our long-term national security,” Kirby warned.
Promotion lists personally altered
Kirby said Hegseth personally removed qualified officers from promotion lists on three occasions during the year, including after military-service leaders reportedly refused requests to take them off.
The officers had already been approved by promotion boards.
Approximately half of those removed were women or Black officers, Kirby wrote.
At the same time, the proportion of senior-officer nominations going to women has reportedly fallen to its lowest level in more than two decades.
The numbers have intensified concerns that Hegseth’s campaign against diversity, equity and inclusion programs has expanded into a broader effort that disadvantages women and minorities regardless of their records or qualifications.
The Pentagon’s stated rationale for individual personnel decisions was not detailed in the supplied report. Kirby’s conclusion that the moves constitute a coordinated campaign against female leadership represents his analysis.
Women’s combat roles placed under review
Women have served in combat-related positions for more than 30 years and have formally served in ground-combat roles for approximately a decade.
Nevertheless, Hegseth ordered a new review of women’s participation in combat roles. He also disbanded the Defense Advisory Committee on Women in the Services, a nonpartisan body that had advised the Pentagon on policies affecting female service members.
Kirby argued that these decisions carry consequences extending beyond equality or symbolism.
America relies on an all-volunteer military. Women account for approximately 10 percent of Marine Corps personnel and closer to 20 percent across the other services.
Only a small number of military specialties operate without female participation.
“Our military cannot afford to deprive itself of this talent,” Kirby wrote.
He also defended the importance of a force reflecting the population it protects, especially when the armed services must persuade civilians from every background to volunteer.
Recruitment figures may conceal future trouble
Pentagon officials have pointed to strong recruitment numbers as evidence that the department’s policy changes are not deterring volunteers.
Kirby disputed that conclusion.
He argued that current recruitment totals partly reflect initiatives established before Hegseth took control of the Pentagon. He also noted that weak economic conditions can push more people toward military service by reducing opportunities in the civilian job market.
Recruitment data are “lagging indicators,” Kirby warned. In other words, today’s figures may reflect earlier policies rather than the long-term consequences of decisions being implemented now.
If women begin to believe they will face restricted career paths, fewer promotion opportunities or institutional hostility, the impact may emerge gradually through lower enlistment, reduced retention and the departure of talented officers.
By the time that damage becomes visible in headline recruitment statistics, rebuilding trust could take years.
Experienced commanders removed
Kirby highlighted several prominent female commanders whose careers ended under Hegseth.
Four-star Adm. Lisa Franchetti was removed approximately one month after Hegseth’s appointment. Air Force Lt. Gen. Jennifer Short was also fired despite an extensive aviation career that included more than 1,800 hours flying the A-10 Warthog.
Navy Vice Adm. Shoshana Chatfield lost her position after assuming a leadership role at NATO headquarters.
Kirby said he knew and served alongside each of the women.
“They were fine leaders and good people,” he wrote.
Hegseth frequently speaks about making the military more lethal. Kirby turned that language against him.
“These women kicked lethality’s butt,” the retired admiral declared.
Their removal did not merely eliminate names from an organizational chart, he argued. It stripped the military of decades of operational knowledge, command experience and institutional judgment.
“Replacing their wisdom and experience will take at least a decade—if we’re lucky,” Kirby warned.
A promotion system at risk of politicization
Civilian leaders have lawful authority over the armed forces, including significant influence over senior personnel decisions.
The danger, Kirby argued, emerges when professional military advancement appears governed by ideology or personal preference rather than experience and merit.
If officers believe that promotion depends on conforming to a political agenda, the effect could reach far beyond the individuals removed. Commanders may become more cautious, professional advice may be softened and institutional independence could deteriorate.
Kirby connected Hegseth’s decisions with his longstanding public views about women in military service and a recent controversy involving alleged body-shaming of a Canadian teenage cadet.
Taken together, Kirby said, the record indicates an effort to diminish female leadership.
“Hegseth is not just campaigning against DEI; he’s campaigning against DNA,” he wrote.
It was a deliberately provocative conclusion: Women may technically remain eligible for military leadership, but Kirby believes the pathway to the highest ranks is narrowing around them.
For a volunteer force dependent on attracting and retaining the country’s best talent, that message could be devastating.
The cost, Kirby warned, would not fall only on the women denied opportunities. It would be paid by the military—and ultimately by the country it exists to defend.
