CBS Killed Colbert’s ‘Late Show’—Now His Abandoned Writers Are Plotting a Spectacular Comeback on Television’s Biggest Night

Stephen Colbert’s writers may have lost their late-night home, but they are not disappearing quietly.

Only months after CBS pulled the plug on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, the acclaimed comedy team has landed a high-profile new assignment: helping Mariska Hargitay take command of the Emmy Awards stage.

The development gives the displaced writers an unexpected opportunity to return to national television—and possibly deliver their sharpest material yet—during one of the entertainment industry’s most closely watched nights.

Hargitay, best known for playing the relentlessly serious Detective Olivia Benson on Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, revealed that she has been working closely with Colbert’s former team as she prepares to host the September ceremony.

“I’m working with an incredible team of writers—the writers from Colbert,” Hargitay told Deadline. “We’ve been meeting a lot and discussing a lot and pitching a lot of ideas. We’re pitching so many ideas.”

Hargitay will host the show for the first time in September.

The process, she emphasized, remains in its earliest and most unpredictable phase.

“We’re at the beginning stages,” she said, “and so we’re throwing out a lot of different ideas.”

The announcement carries an unmistakable sense of vindication for writers who recently claimed that CBS had left them without meaningful support as Emmy voting approached.

After The Late Show ended, the writing staff said the network was not mounting a “For Your Consideration” campaign on their behalf. Instead of accepting that quietly, they created their own.

“CBS is not doing a For Your Consideration campaign for us, so, ‘for strictly financial reasons,’ the @colbertlateshow writers made our own #FYC campaign,” the team wrote in an Instagram caption.

The phrase “strictly financial reasons” was a pointed reference to CBS and Paramount’s explanation for ending the program. Their homemade campaign video, styled like a bright 1980s sitcom, carried the title: “We’d Love an Emmy.”

Colbert’s writers called out CBS for not pushing their awards in June.

Now, those same writers are preparing jokes for the Emmy broadcast itself.

The assignment arrives after a dramatic and politically charged ending to one of American television’s most prominent late-night programs.

The Late Show aired its final episode in May following years in which Colbert repeatedly targeted Donald Trump with blistering monologues. The host intensified his criticism in July when he accused Paramount of “bribing” the president by agreeing to a $16.5 million settlement related to Trump’s complaints about a 2024 interview with his political opponent.

Days later, Paramount announced that The Late Show franchise would end.

The company has maintained that the cancellation was made for purely financial reasons. At the time, Paramount was also preparing for a major deal involving Skydance, an entertainment company viewed as more accommodating to MAGA-aligned politics.

The timing fueled widespread suspicion among critics, but no public evidence cited in the supplied reporting establishes that Colbert’s political attacks caused the cancellation.

Mariska Hargitay as Olivia Benson in ‘Law & Order: Special Victims Unit’

Whatever happened behind corporate doors, the show’s creative team is now receiving a striking new platform.

Hargitay will make her Emmy-hosting debut on September 14. Although her résumé includes 10 Emmy nominations and one victory for portraying Olivia Benson, some viewers have questioned whether an actress so closely associated with grim criminal investigations is a natural choice to host a comedy-heavy awards broadcast.

Hargitay insists that humor is far closer to her real personality than audiences might realize.

“If you came to the set of SVU and you saw how we cope with things and the long hours and the subject matter, there’s a lot of joking because it’s a marathon,” she explained.

“I think I’ve always used humor to cope with everything,” Hargitay continued. “Olivia Benson is a character that I live in a box. That’s a character. But if you knew me, I live in the comedy world.”

One possible Emmy-night joke is already taking shape around a strange request Hargitay receives from other celebrities.

“I cannot tell you how many people—famous people—ask to be a dead body on the show,” she said. “It’s on their bucket list.”

That bizarre Hollywood obsession has become one of the ideas Hargitay and the Colbert writers are discussing—raising the possibility of an opening bit filled with celebrity “victims,” an SVU-style mystery or both.

“The Late Show” aired its last episode on May 21.

The writers also have a deeply personal reason to make the broadcast unforgettable.

The Late Show with Stephen Colbert received nine Emmy nominations for its final year—the highest total in its history. Its nominations include Outstanding Variety Series, Writing and Directing, along with recognition for production design, camerawork, lighting, sound, editing and music direction.

CBS may have closed the studio and extinguished the lights on Colbert’s nightly stage.

But on Emmy night, his writers will be back in the room, shaping the jokes and controlling the rhythm of the broadcast.

And if their work wins—or if Hargitay delivers the television moment everyone remembers—the team CBS allegedly left to campaign for itself could have the most satisfying final line of all.

Leave a Reply