Hollywood Almost Cast Her as Superman’s Great Love—But a Terrifying Affair Made Her the Wife America Couldn’t Forget

She stands near the bathroom door, soaked and terrified, watching the life she trusted collapse into violence.

For most of the film, she has been the innocent person inside someone else’s secret. Her husband has betrayed her. A stranger has entered her home. By the final moments, the quiet wife must become the person capable of ending the nightmare herself.

That scene turned a respected working actress into an Academy Award nominee.

Yet the woman behind the role had already spent her entire life surrounded by Hollywood illusions.

Born in Los Angeles, she was the daughter of two performers. Her father appeared in films and television, while her mother became familiar to millions through a long-running family sitcom. Acting was therefore not a distant fantasy—it was the family business waiting just outside her bedroom door.

But having famous parents did not guarantee her success.

After graduating from Pitzer College, she performed in a long-running outdoor production before moving to New York. In 1971, she received the ceremonial title of Miss Golden Globe, an honor traditionally given to the child of someone within the entertainment industry.

A year later, she made her feature-film debut.

The early roles arrived steadily but without creating a sensation. She appeared opposite James Coburn, Sam Elliott, Chuck Norris, Sylvester Stallone and John Ritter. She moved between Westerns, dramas, comedies and television series, becoming recognizable without yet becoming unforgettable.

She also came remarkably close to entering superhero history.

During the 1970s, she auditioned to play Lois Lane in Superman. The role eventually went to Margot Kidder, leaving behind one of those tantalizing Hollywood questions: how different might her career have looked if she had become the woman beside Christopher Reeve?

Instead, another wife would define her legacy.

In 1987, she entered a psychological thriller about a married attorney whose weekend affair becomes increasingly dangerous. Michael Douglas played the unfaithful husband. Glenn Close played the woman who refused to disappear quietly.

The third member of that explosive triangle had the most deceptively difficult role.

As Beth Gallagher, she needed to embody the security her husband endangered: marriage, home, motherhood and trust. She could not appear weak, but the story required her to remain unaware of the truth for much of the film.

Then everything erupted.

The movie became a cultural phenomenon, provoking arguments about infidelity, obsession, marriage and the way women were portrayed. Its most notorious sequence involving a family pet entered popular culture, while its violent finale left audiences cheering, disturbed or both.

That finale was not the original ending.

The first version concluded very differently, but test audiences rejected it. The studio demanded a more explosive confrontation in which the betrayed wife would fight the other woman inside the family home.

The actress playing Beth was reportedly deeply upset when she heard that the ending would be replaced. Yet the reshot sequence gave her character a final burst of agency—and created one of the most famous climaxes in thriller history.

Her restrained performance earned nominations for an Oscar, a BAFTA and a Golden Globe.

After that breakthrough, she avoided becoming trapped as television’s permanently betrayed wife. She played the spouse of CIA analyst Jack Ryan in Patriot Games and Clear and Present Danger, bringing emotional weight to the political thrillers starring Harrison Ford.

She also joined Robert Altman’s sprawling ensemble drama Short Cuts. The cast collectively received major recognition, including a special Golden Globe and an ensemble honor at the Venice Film Festival.

Then, at an age when Hollywood often begins reducing opportunities for women, she made another provocative move.

She stepped onto the London stage as Mrs. Robinson in The Graduate—the seductive older woman who destabilizes a young man’s life. It was a striking reversal: the actress once famous as the wife threatened by an affair was now playing one of popular culture’s most celebrated temptresses.

Her private life contained its own long and complicated chapters.

She married William Davis in 1969 and had a son with him before their divorce in 1977. Two years later, she married writer, producer and director Terry Jastrow. They welcomed another son and remained together across decades of Hollywood change.

Religion also became a highly visible part of the family story.

She and her husband became members of the Church of Scientology in the 1970s. She later served as a spokesperson for an education organization associated with the church. Her older son eventually became one of Scientology’s most prominent public representatives, placing the family near controversies that extended far beyond film.

The actress herself increasingly divided her time among acting, humanitarian advocacy and theater. She co-founded Artists for Human Rights with her husband and continued returning to performance in carefully chosen projects.

Her career is filled with roads almost taken: the superhero romance she nearly entered, the original movie ending audiences never accepted, and the roles she used to escape the image of the perfect suburban wife.

Yet one performance remains impossible to forget.

The woman who survived cinema’s most infamous affair as Beth Gallagher, stood beside Harrison Ford’s Jack Ryan and nearly became Lois Lane is Anne Archer.

Leave a Reply