Donald Trump’s long-running legal battle with writer E. Jean Carroll has entered a new and increasingly tense phase — just days after the Supreme Court shut the door on his appeal.
Now, Carroll’s attorney is accusing the president of trying to delay the inevitable.
Trump owes Carroll nearly $5.8 million, including interest, after a federal jury found him liable in 2023 for sexually abusing and defaming her. The Supreme Court declined on June 29 to review that verdict, leaving the judgment intact.
For Carroll, the ruling was supposed to mark the end of one chapter in a legal fight that has stretched across years, multiple courts and repeated appeals.
For Trump, it appears to have opened another fight over time.
Carroll’s attorney, Roberta Kaplan, filed a sharp response Friday after Trump asked U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan for more time to respond to Carroll’s motion demanding payment. Trump’s lawyers argued that a new attorney needed time to get up to speed on the case.
Carroll’s legal team was not persuaded.
“Defendant’s assertion that he cannot respond to Plaintiff’s Motion on the timeline ordered by the Court appears to be little more than yet another play for time,” Kaplan wrote, according to the court filing.
The message was blunt: after years of litigation, appeals and delays, Carroll’s side says Trump has run out of reasons not to pay.
“We can only assume that Defendant is seeking, through the instant motion, to buy time so he can try to concoct some new basis to put off paying Plaintiff,” Kaplan added.
The clash comes after the nation’s highest court refused to take up Trump’s challenge to the 2023 verdict.
The Supreme Court did not explain its decision, as is typical when it declines to hear a case. No justice publicly dissented. The result left standing a Manhattan jury’s finding that Trump was liable for sexually abusing Carroll in the mid-1990s and defaming her in 2022 when he publicly denied her account.
Trump has consistently denied Carroll’s allegations and has called the case politically motivated.
But legally, the Supreme Court’s action was a major defeat.
The $5 million verdict, which has grown to approximately $5.8 million with interest, is now final unless Trump can find some other successful legal avenue to avoid or delay enforcement. Carroll’s lawyers moved quickly after the ruling, asking the court to order Trump to pay.
Trump’s latest request for more time centers on attorney Josh Halpern, who recently joined the defense team.
But legal analyst Roger Parloff questioned the argument publicly, noting that Trump had known for months that his lead lawyer was departing and that other lawyers had already been working on the case.
That detail intensified the criticism that the request was less about preparation and more about postponement.
For Carroll, the payment dispute is not an isolated fight. It is part of a larger legal saga that has repeatedly returned to the same issue: whether Trump can keep challenging judgments that courts have already upheld.
The former Elle advice columnist first publicly accused Trump in 2019. In 2023, a jury awarded her $5 million after finding Trump liable in the civil case. A separate jury in 2024 ordered Trump to pay Carroll $83.3 million for defamatory statements he made after her initial victory. That second, much larger judgment remains under appeal.
The difference between the two cases matters.
The $5 million judgment has now survived the trial, appellate review and Trump’s attempt to bring the matter before the Supreme Court. The $83.3 million judgment is still moving through the legal system.
That makes the smaller amount, in some ways, more politically significant right now.
It is the bill Trump can no longer describe as unresolved.
Carroll’s legal team argues that the time for more procedural maneuvering has passed. Her lawyers say Trump’s repeated attempts to delay payment have forced her to continue fighting for money a jury awarded more than three years ago.
Trump’s attorneys, meanwhile, are expected to argue that new counsel needs a fair chance to review the record before responding.
The judge will decide whether that explanation is enough.
But the optics are already brutal.
Trump has spent years insisting the case should never have moved forward. He lost at trial. He lost at the appeals court. He lost at the Supreme Court.
Now, Carroll’s attorney says he is trying one more familiar strategy: run out the clock.
For Carroll, the question is no longer whether the verdict stands.
It does.
The question is how much longer she will have to wait before Trump pays it.
