President Donald Trump, 79, has made his most audacious legal move yet — asking the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn the $5 million civil verdict that found him liable for sexually abusing and defaming writer E. Jean Carroll.
The former president’s petition to the high court, filed Monday, marks his last-ditch effort to erase a legal defeat that has haunted him for years — a case that bridged decades of denial, courtroom drama, and personal humiliation.
Trump’s legal team framed the Carroll case as “a politically motivated witch hunt,” arguing that the decades-old allegation was unsupported by evidence and timed to inflict maximum damage.
“There were no eyewitnesses, no video evidence, and no police report or investigation,” the filing reads. “Instead, Carroll waited more than 20 years to falsely accuse Donald Trump, who she politically opposes, until after he became the 45th president, when she could maximize political injury to him and profit for herself.”
Carroll, now 81, first accused Trump in 2019, writing that he had sexually assaulted her in a department store dressing room in the mid-1990s. Trump’s furious denial — “She’s not my type,” he said — triggered a defamation lawsuit that would come to define both their reputations.

In 2023, a federal jury ruled that Trump had sexually abused and defamed Carroll, awarding her $5 million in damages. When Trump refused to apologize and doubled down on his claims, she sued him again — and won an additional $83.3 million in a second case last year.
The verdicts made Carroll one of the few women in U.S. history to successfully hold a sitting or former president accountable for sexual misconduct.
Now, Trump’s lawyers are pleading with the nation’s highest court to intervene, arguing that the trial was tainted by “prejudicial evidence” and “biased rulings” — particularly the judge’s decision to allow testimony from another woman who alleged Trump groped her on an airplane in 1979.
According to the filing, that testimony “poisoned the jury” by creating the impression of a “pattern” of sexual misconduct. But Carroll’s attorney Roberta Kaplan dismissed the argument, saying federal rules explicitly permit such evidence in sexual assault cases.

“Even if the court had been incorrect,” Kaplan told The Daily Beast Podcast, “it would be considered a harmless error — because we had another 10 or 11 witnesses, and they had zero.”
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals agreed, upholding the verdict last year. Now, all that stands between Trump and final judgment is whether the Supreme Court chooses to hear the case. So far, it hasn’t.
Legal analysts say Trump’s odds are slim. “The Supreme Court rarely takes civil cases like this — especially ones that don’t raise constitutional issues,” said former U.S. attorney Barbara McQuade. “This is a factual dispute Trump already lost twice. There’s nothing SCOTUS-worthy here.”
Carroll herself seems unfazed by Trump’s latest move. Speaking recently to CNN, she said she plans to donate most of the awarded money “to everything Donald Trump hates,” including organizations protecting women’s reproductive rights and voting rights.
Her message was as defiant as ever: “I don’t want his money. I want him held accountable.”
Trump’s spokesperson, meanwhile, painted the petition as part of a broader campaign against what they call “liberal lawfare.” “The American people stand with President Trump as they demand an immediate end to all of the witch hunts,” the statement read. “He will keep winning against these politically motivated attacks.”
But behind the bluster lies a reality that even Trump can’t easily rewrite. For years, he’s insisted he never met Carroll — despite a photograph showing them together at a party in the 1980s. That claim unraveled in court when jurors saw the image, shaking their heads as Trump’s own defense faltered.

Carroll’s attorney reminded the jury that Trump’s denial — “She’s not my type” — echoed the same contempt he showed toward every woman who ever accused him. “That’s his pattern,” Kaplan said. “He doesn’t just assault — he humiliates.”
For Trump, the Supreme Court plea may serve another purpose: delay. By appealing, he can postpone paying the judgment — and keep the story alive on his terms, as another front in his war against the so-called “deep state.”
Yet even among conservative legal observers, skepticism is growing. “He’s not just fighting the law,” one Republican strategist said. “He’s fighting the facts, the evidence, and time itself. Eventually, that runs out.”
The $5 million judgment from the first case currently sits in a court-controlled account, quietly accruing interest. The second, $83 million verdict is winding its way through appeals.
Trump’s legal calendar, already jammed with criminal trials, depositions, and civil suits, is now a roadmap of reckoning.
And while the Supreme Court hasn’t yet weighed in, its silence so far says plenty.
For Carroll, who once wrote that she told her story to reclaim her voice, this final chapter feels like vindication. For Trump, it may be a reminder that even the most powerful man in the world can’t escape the judgment of twelve ordinary citizens — or the words carved above the Court he’s now begging to save him:
“Equal Justice Under Law.”
